The Mariners’ Decade of Mind-Numbing All-Star Misfortune

delabarBack in July of 2003 I was a lazy 18-year-old just a few weeks removed from my high school graduation. I was working a part-time job at Champs Sports and sitting around my parents’ house in my spare time. It was the last summer before college and I wasn’t doing much of anything at all. So naturally on the 15th day of the month, I found myself watching the 74th annual Major League Baseball All-Star Game.

The two rosters that day featured such greats as Montreal Expos second baseman Jose Vidro (the National League’s starting second baseman), New York Mets closer Armando Benitez, Milwaukee Brewers first baseman Richie Sexson, Chicago White Sox designated hitter Carl Everett, token Kansas City Royal Mike Sweeney, and Minnesota Twins relief pitcher Eddie Guardado. If you don’t know the bond that those six seemingly random former All-Stars share, then you obviously aren’t a Mariners fan.

More important than the sextet of “stars” who would later become white dwarfs in Seattle, however, were the five current Mariners playing in baseball’s summer showcase that year: second baseman Bret Boone, setup man-turned-closer Shigetoshi Hasegawa, designated hitter Edgar Martinez, veteran fireballer Jamie Moyer, and of course right fielder Ichiro Suzuki. It was a good year for M’s at the All-Star Game and unbeknownst to fans like you and I, the last time that many members of our hometown nine would find themselves at the Classic…ever.

In the ensuing years, the Mariners would earn one, maybe two All-Star nods on an annual basis. In 2011, a year in which the team lost 95 games as well as their manager, a whopping three M’s (Felix Hernandez, Brandon League, and Michael Pineda) found their way to Arizona to represent the Emerald City on baseball’s brightest stage. But in general, the decade that followed the 2003 edition of baseball’s talent show was one of relative emptiness for your Seattle Mariners, both with respect to the All-Star Game itself and the team’s slog through 162 games each year.

The general struggles of the Mariners have been chronicled in great detail, so no need to rehash that. But in examining All-Star rosters between 2004 and 2013, the story gets much more stomach-churning.

It’s bad enough that in 10 years the M’s have only sent seven different players (Ichiro, Jose Lopez, J.J. Putz, Hisashi Iwakuma, and the aforementioned trio of Hernandez, League, and Pineda) to the Classic, spread across a total of 16 selections (or 1.6 selections per year). It gets much, much worse when you take into account the 47 All-Star selections earned by the 23 unique former Mariners over that same span. Yes, you read that right. From 2004 to 2013, 23 former M’s have become All-Stars, while only seven current M’s have done the same. Likewise, those 23 former M’s have paraded through home run derbies, celebrity softball games, and fan meet-and-greets 47 different times — an average of 2.3 unique players and 4.7 selections every freakin’ year.

To put this all into context, consider that you could nearly field an entire 25-man roster solely comprised of former Mariners that have made the All-Star game in the past decade. Here’s what your squad would look like:

C – Jason Varitek
1B – Bryan LaHair
2B – Asdrubal Cabrera
SS – Alex Rodriguez
3B – Adrian Beltre
LF – Raul Ibanez
CF – Ken Griffey, Jr.
RF – Adam Jones
DH – David Ortiz

INF – Carlos Guillen
OF – Scott Podsednik

Starting Rotation
SP – Randy Johnson
SP – Cliff Lee
SP – R.A. Dickey
SP – Gil Meche
SP – Chris Tillman

RP – Steve Delabar
RP – Ryan Franklin
RP – Brian Fuentes
RP – Arthur Rhodes
RP – George Sherrill
RP – Rafael Soriano
RP – Matt Thornton

Sure, you’d have an abundance of pitchers (and Bryan LaHair at first base — remember when he made the All-Star team? It was one year ago, yet seems like forever), but who really cares? Any general manager in the game would kill for the talent on the roster you see above. All of it just goes to show how badly management has run this team into the ground over the past ten years.

Now of course any one of us could glance at that list of ex-Mariners and start to qualify all the couldawouldashouldas that may have impacted the respective departures of each player, but why do that? It’s irrelevant. When you’re dealing with a sample size this great, a lesson in egregious mismanagement this massive, does it even matter? Does it even matter whether one guy left for more money, or another was dealt for a promising return, or yet another was a Single-A prospect we knew little about when we pawned him off on a rival? No. None of it matters. Because the fact is we had all these guys and we let them go. We dated 23 of the prettiest girls in school and ended up with a miserable, ugly bitch instead. We controlled our destiny and we screwed it all up. And in fairness, when I say “we” did all this, I don’t mean you or I (because neither you nor I would ever be this stupid), but the collective “we” that is the Mariners. We are really dumb sometimes.

If I had any idea on July 15th, 2003 how incredibly awful my baseball team would soon become, I probably would have soaked in the day’s lone contest like a prisoner enjoying his final meal. Instead, I took it all for granted and never saw the demise coming. And damn it, that blows.

Shit. Shit, shit, shit. Look, we all get it. The Mariners have produced 10 years of festering waste for a reason. When you look at the recent history of the All-Star game alone, it becomes pretty clear what the No. 1 reason may be.

We had it and we lost it. We were rich with talent and we squandered it all. We spent our stars faster than M.C. Hammer spent all his money. We made bad decision after bad decision and look where it’s led us: twelve years without a playoff berth.

Screw those guys in the front office. And here’s hoping it gets better.

7 thoughts on “The Mariners’ Decade of Mind-Numbing All-Star Misfortune”

  1. Yep, traded him for a bucket of Rawlings baseballs and a box of Bazooka Joe just now. No, actually we didn’t do that. Don’t know how Iwakuma snuck into the list of former M’s, but that’s now been corrected. Thanks for catching that.

    And to all of you who read this article from here on out, you can thank Mike for helping bring you a (hopefully) error-free assessment of Mariner ineptitude. Errors? What errors?

  2. “We dated 23 of the prettiest girls in school and ended up with a miserable, ugly bitch instead.” Yikes, dude. I understand that you’re venting, but you gotta choose a less misogynistic/hateful analogy…

  3. Sad thing I see is a lack of good hitters the past decade. Outside of Ichiro, we’ve had just one All-Star position player the past decade (Jose freaking Lopez) and we’ve had no participants in even the Home Run Derby since 2003 (Bret Boone).

    Bill Bavasi put us in such a hole that I will never, ever forgive that man.

  4. I see these lists all the time, and they never really make sense to me. Let’s take a real good look at the better players on it.

    Raul Ibanez, Adrian Beltre, Alex Rodriguez, Randy Johnson, and RA Dickey all left during free agency. Dollars for donuts they didn’t wanna sign back in Seattle. For that matter, Bryan Lahair left as a free agent as well. David Ortiz was traded when he was young, but it wasn’t until he signed as a free agent with Boston that he became the Big Papi that we know so well.

    Griffey forced a trade, and Cliff Lee was traded from some valuable pieces himself, before resigning elsewhere after the single season that the Mariners had his rights as…wait for it, yeah, a free agent.

    Yes, a few of the relievers went on to do good things. But ya know what? That’s generally how relievers work. They’re hard to predict, come and go after a few years of productivity, and the Mariners have picked up their share of strong guys in the bullpen from unorthodox places in their own right. I’m not terribly fussed about them, really.

    Which leaves with just a few guys, from just a couple transactions. Jason Varitek, Asdrubal Cabrera, Adam Jones and the unlisted but All Star caliber Shin-Soo Choo. These guys are the ones that really counted. Yes, they were bad deals.

    But let’s not act like the entire roster could have been Mariners the whole length of their careers. They didn’t want to be. They signed elsewhere. I have no idea if the Mariners tried to get them or not, but to blame the Mariners for not signing a free agent, you might as well blame them for not signing ANY good free agent from the open market. And you can do that, sure. But it won’t make the most sense.

  5. Excellent beat ! I wish to apprentice at the
    same time as you amend your website, how can i subscribe for a blog website?
    The account helped me a appropriate deal. I were a little bit acquainted of
    this your broadcast provided vibrant clear concept

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s