Dropping Griffey, Sweeney Won’t Solve Problems

As the saying goes, it’s only a problem if you have a solution. And frankly, when it comes to the Mariners’ designated hitter tandem of Mike Sweeney and Ken Griffey Jr., solutions are nowhere to be found.

Much has been made in recent days of the hitting woes shared by two veterans with 76 years of life between them (Sweeney is 36; Griffey, 40). Their combined batting average is .211 (16-for-76). They have managed just one extra-base hit (a double, by Griffey). They have produced a grand total of six RBI. They have eight bases on balls to their credit, but mitigate the on-base percentage with their 14 strikeouts. To say that the Mariners’ DH position is a veritable black hole would be entirely accurate.

But let’s be real for a minute. What other options does the team have?

I suppose, the Mariners could call up a player from the minors to fill the void. But it’s always a risky move taking a prospect and attempting to turn him into a designated hitter from the get-go (see Jeff Clement). Not to mention the fact that there is no one worthy of such a promotion in the farm system at this point in time. Currently, the two best hitters at Triple-A Tacoma are middle infielders Josh Wilson and Chris Woodward, neither of whom would be counted on to provide pop in the heart of a major league lineup. So that’s out.

Then you have the possibility of a trade. Except at this point we’d be speaking in hypotheticals. So why even go there?

The reality is this: If a guy isn’t on your active roster or in your system, he cannot be had without giving up something in return. And what do the Mariners really have that they could give up to obtain a big-league slugger? The cupboard isn’t bare, but it certainly isn’t full. Meaning the number of tradeable commodities within the organization are few and far between. Can we make a trade happen? Yes. Will we make a trade happen? Not right now. So get that thought out of your head for the time being.

You can always sign what few available free agents remain, I guess. The name Jermaine Dye has surfaced in recent weeks. But Dye is 36 years of age, same as Sweeney, and there’s no telling what kind of shape he’s in at the moment. Even though he showed signs of a life a year ago with 27 home runs, he still batted just .250. And trust me, folks, there’s a reason he’s out of baseball. Thirty franchises can’t be wrong. So yet again, we find ourselves between a rock and a hard place.

As we stand here discussing the issue, the Mariners have no other options besides what they currently possess. That means if neither Sweeney nor Griffey can iron out their wrinkles in the immediate future, perhaps some lineup tinkering is in order.

Maybe Matt Tuiasosopo or Eric Byrnes could earn themselves more playing time.

Maybe Milton Bradley could find himself logging more at-bats at DH.

Maybe we’ll just let the pitchers hit. Keep in mind that Felix Hernandez once hit a grand slam off of Johan Santana, Jason Vargas was a full-time batter in college, and Cliff Lee posted a batting average of .212 with the Phillies last year. Anyone? No? Okay, fine. We’ll just let that one go.

Until we get closer to the trading deadline in July, the Mariners are going to look very similar to the way they do now. So get used to it, M’s fans. Because Mike Sweeney and Ken Griffey Jr. are likely here to stay. For now, at least.

4 thoughts on “Dropping Griffey, Sweeney Won’t Solve Problems”


    No one ever seems to think about how bad the solution (i.e. more Byrnes/Tui, etc.) when they talk about dumping Sweeney and/or benching Jr.

  2. For the record I think it should be mentioned that Felix is the only player to finish with a 1.000 Slugging for the season, because that grand slam was his only at bat.

  3. Put Sweeney on the DL, make JR a situational pinch hitter, move Bradley to DH, call up Saunders to play LF. Saunders is a better defender, and keeping Bradley from playing defense will keep him healthy longer. JR and Sweeney get to stay around and give hugs. This needs to happen, and it’s not easy for me to say my childhood hero needs to be benched.

  4. The problem is not so much the lack of production at the plate, but the inflexibility to the roster that results from both being on the team. With a 12 man pitching staff, Rob Johnson’s Stellar CERA, (Which luckily isn’t affected by passed balls) and the injury risks of Bradley, Wilson and Byrnes, having a DH platoon that can’t hit and can’t field is a luxury the team can’t afford. Bringing up Saunders might not significantly improve our offense, but it will improve Wak’s flexibility. I love seeing Griffey on the team as much as the next guy, but I also don’t believe the M’s are better when he is on the field.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s